Honestly, I would eat these. They are crunchy and oven-baked (slowly, to lock in that flavor). Speaking of flavor, how do peanut butter, molasses, apples, and carrots sound? They are made in North America with no artificial preservatives (shelf life is courtesy of mixed tocopherols, which our experts tell us are a safe way to preserve, vs. BHA, BHT, etc.). Trust me that you’ll want this value size!

Old Mother Hubbard lives up to her name… the company was established in 1926 so has been making pups slobber for decades. They are A-OK for all life stages and breed sizes and tout an impressive 96% recommendation rate on Chewy for the P-Nuttier Biscuits. Take a look at some 5-star reviews: “I have two dogs. One older Westie who is very sensitive to treats of any kind. She has a tummy that doesn’t tolerate many things. She loves these treats, and they don’t bother her sensitive tummy. My other girl loves them too! I feel good about Old Mother Hubbard products.” “My dog, Dobby, loves these so much that he doesn’t stop for pets or “good boys” after he potties. He makes a beeline for the door and doesn’t want pets until he gets this treat. He doesn’t do that when any other treat is in the treat jar.”

Information as of 3/31/22